National Popular Vote Bill Is Wrong For California & Even Worse for Republicans
The NPV bill before the California legislature is bad for America and even worse for California Republicans. I could not be more against this effort.
First, in an era of growing awareness of the need to respect the Constitution, support for an unprecedented end run around the Constitutional amendment process could not be more untimely let alone “extra-constitutional” -- if not out-right unconstitutional. If such a core Constitutional process as the Electoral College can be averted by this scheme, what would be next and where would it end? I have no desire to know the answer to those questions.
Second, there was a reason why our Founders did not want a popular vote system. I remain persuaded by their arguments that have withstood the test of time over those pushing for the effective repeal of the Electoral College today.
Third, the map above should persuade everyone that this effort will result in an even more divided America. The Democrats will concentrate on certain states and the blue tower areas – especially Los Angeles - and Republicans will concentrate on the red areas. The further balkanization of America is a bad idea and one major reason the Electoral College exists. Our Founders wanted to give Delaware a chance against Virginia. So they gave Delaware a greater voice in choosing the Presidency than just the popular vote. As such, they wouldn’t want California, Illinois, and New York to dominate our process even more than they already do.
Fourth, in no uncertain terms, that means that Republicans within the LA media market will have a much harder time getting elected. Seductive claims of more Republican money aside, the bottom line is that Democrats will run more ads in the Los Angeles area to run up their vote totals and that will harm the chances of any Republicans within range of that media market. Given the pending redistricting, Republicans cannot possibly benefit from more Democrat money in that area.
In sum, this is a bad bill that runs contrary to the very fabric of our Constitution. The Founders reached a better solution. I am sticking with that and I more than hope that every State legislature in America does the same.
I urge you to contact your state representative and urge them to vote against this bill.